“I was disappointed,” CryertoldEWon the film’s 20th anniversary in 2006.

“You sorta go, ‘Oh, guess I’m not the leading man.’

But I think it was kind of appropriate.

Jon Cryer, Molly Ringwald, … | It’s the most controversial ending in teen movie history: In John Hughes' original script, Andie stayed with eccentric, devoted best friend Duckie at the prom,

Everett Collection

Duckie always thought he was the leading man, and that was his fatal flaw.

I got it at the time.

Class lines aren’t worth crossing.'

Bill Pullman, Sandra Bullock, … | Yes, the plot is ridiculous: A lonely subway token collector (Bullock) saves the life of the rich, handsome commuter (Gallagher) she fantasizes about marrying. While

Everett Collection (2)

That said, having one third of the triangle unresponsive for most of the film is different.

In the battle of love,creme brulee unfortunately beats Jell-O.

We still love you, Jell-O.

Cameron Diaz, Julia Roberts, … | What did this heart-wrenching love triangle teach us (aside from ‘‘Say a Little Prayer’’ is best sung during brunch)? In the battle of love, crème

Everett Collection

At least they flung each other in water instead of through a glass window this time.

It was more romantic than it sounds, we swear.

Bella must choose between her platonic love for her best friend and romantic love for her cold-blooded boyfriend.

It could have been the girly kicking, or even the hair pulling, but watching British studs Hugh Grant and Colin Firth fight over Renée Zellweger

Jason Bell

In the end, Team Edward comes out on top in all his glittery glory.

The result: a sultry and volatile love triangle.

Scott was killed by Jean’s alternate personality “Phoenix,” who proceeded to destroy the world.

Johnny Depp, Orlando Bloom, … | Avast ye, Elizabeth Swan, you get marooned on an idyllic island with barrels of rum and a swashbuckling Jack Sparrow and it’s still not enough

Everett Collection

Still, our heart bleeds most for Scott, whose love literally killed him.

(Note: That’s no way to treat someone who spirals into a depression after your death!)

But it planted the seeds, and the drama bloomed from there.

Keira Knightley, Chiwetel Ejiofor, … | Movie theaters around the world reverberated with the sounds of hearts breaking as we watched poor Mark reveal that he didn’t actually dislike his best

Everett Collection (2)

And that was just the beginning.

At least until the word “cougar” snuck into our lexicon.

Of course, Westley and Buttercup end up together.

Taylor Lautner, Kristen Stewart, … | It’s hard not to be aware of the melodramatic teen love between toned werewolf Jacob, broody vamp Edward Cullen, and mere mortal Bella Swann. Bella

Summit Entertainment

Just as you wish(ed).

Javier Bardem, Penelope Cruz, … | Few women are crazier than artist Juan Antonio’s knife-wielding ex-wife Maria Elena, especially when young daredevil Cristina and her friend accept Juan’s invite to spend

Victor Bello

Ben Stiller, Ethan Hawke, … | Recently graduated Lelaina is stuck between stable nice guy Michael and less stable slacker Troy. Against the backdrop of a ’90s coming-of-age story steeped in

Everett Collection

Jean may have had an official romance with Scott, but it’s hard to ignore the less-than-subtle looks from ruggedly handsome Logan over the course of

Everett Collection (2)

Billy Zane, Kate Winslet, … | There was really no competition when Billy Zane’s Cal Hockley (and his bad wig!) found himself having to compete for the heart of his fiancée

Everett Collection (2)

The Hunger Games, The Hunger Games, … | The true weight of the Katniss, Peeta, Gale love triangle didn’t really come through in the first installment of the Hunger Games movie franchise. But

Murray Close/Lionsgate

Clark Gable, Vivien Leigh, … | After the childish and selfish Scarlett set her sights on both romantic Southern gent Ashley and the debonair Rhett, she spent years toying with their

Everett Collection

Anne Bancroft, Dustin Hoffman, … | It’s hard to complicate your life more than young college grad Brad did when he was seduced by the wife of his father’s business partner

Everett Collection

Cary Elwes, Chris Sarandon, … | There was never any real contest for Buttercup’s affection but the dastardly Humperdink was well prepared to kill her true love Westley in order to

Everett Collection (2)