“I would run out and turn all the lights off in the hall,” Samberg remembered.

Andy Sambergis reliving the memories of prankingColin Jost wanna come with?

“I had always assumed ‘Wanna come with’ was for company.

Colin Jost, and actor/TV personality Andy Samberg attend the after party for the New York premiere of “Staten Island Summer” at The Standard Hotel on July 21, 2015 in New York City

Colin Jost and Andy Samberg.Michael Loccisano/Getty

Is it that ‘Wanna come with’ [from] a little bit of fear?

Michael Loccisano/Getty

Samberg admitted that he might have actually been afraid of going to the bathroom alone.

“Probably, yeah,” he said.

Andy Samberg attends the ‘Chip ‘N Dale: Rescue Rangers’ premiere at El Capitan Theatre in Hollywood, California on May 18, 2022

Andy Samberg.Jesse Grant/Getty

I think I’ve talked about that before.

He’d be super scared, obviously.”

“I think I was asked it probably five times a night,” he said.

Thereby not making anyone want to go to the bathroom with you."

Jesse Grant/Getty

ThePopstaractor laughed at the audacity of his rudeness.

“Like, ‘C’mon man, just come with me.’

Like the biggest dick move of all time.”

“He stopped saying it that way.”

Samberg said that the running joke remains intact, and only the phrasing has changed.

“Now I just go like, ‘You wanna come with me to the bathroom?'”

Listen to the most recent conversation between Samberg, Meyers, and Schaffer above.