And our own moms just proved it.

Before that,Jimmy Carter’s grandson was forced outfor very confidently stating Chris was related to Elton John.

And way back on episode 3,Dolly Parton’sniece was expelled for thinking he was a descendant of Elvis.

Chris on ‘Claim to Fame’

Chris on ‘Claim to Fame’.ABC

“What the f—?

Who is this guy?”

one player recently pondered about the unassuming competitor.

‘Claim to Fame’ contestant Chris; Donny Osmond in 1975

‘Claim to Fame’ contestant Chris; Donny Osmond in 1975.ABC/Gizelle Hernandez; ABC Photo Archives/Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

If they are right, the other person is out.

If they are wrong, their own relative is exposed and they are forced to leave instead.

But his fellow players have hilariously not been able to crack it.

EW staff moms guess who a Claim to Fame contestants is related to

Text from an EW staff mom.Courtesy of EW

Check out a sampling of the results below.

Many EW moms guessed Chris was related to theDonny & Mariestar right away.

Also Donny Osmond."

EW staff moms guess who a Claim to Fame contestants is related to

Text from an EW staff mom.Courtesy of EW

Other moms were able to clock him with the clue about being a former teen idol.

He replied with a guess that Chris was Colin Jost and Mark Consuelos' love child.

Now that’s a guesser who would fit right in onClaim to Fame.

EW staff moms guess who a Claim to Fame contestants is related to

Text from an EW staff mom.

Thanks to all the moms who contributed to this story!

EW staff moms guess who a Claim to Fame contestants is related to

Text from an EW staff mom.Courtesy of EW